Skip to content

We may be paid when you use partner links. Who pays us never changes what we show. How we make money

Guide: warranty or insurance

Home warranty vs homeowners insurance

Updated November 17, 2026

They are two different products from two different industries. This page puts what Choice Home Warranty says about each one side by side, in its words, and leaves a dash where it says nothing.

Wear and tear
What a CHW home warranty is for: a service contract, not insurance
Fire, flood, wind
What CHW says homeowners insurance is for: hazard cover

Choice Home Warranty, common questions, read Oct 14, 2026. See source

A couple carrying a moving box up the porch steps of their new house in late afternoon light
On this page
  1. Key facts
  2. Side by side, in Choice Home Warranty's words
  3. What the home warranty is, in CHW's words
  4. What CHW says homeowners insurance is
  5. Why people buy both, and what to read first
  6. The company behind these quotes
  7. Warranty or insurance questions
  8. Sources

Key facts

  • A home warranty is a service contract, in CHW's words 'a service contract that helps protect homeowners against the cost of unexpected covered repairs of their major systems and appliances that break down due to normal wear and tear'1. Its pages add: 'CHW offers service contracts which are not warranties' and the agreement says 'This is not a contract of insurance'13.
  • Homeowners insurance, as CHW describes it, is hazard insurance that 'only covers items damaged in fires, flooding, wind, and other natural disasters'1. CHW's article: 'A home warranty is not a substitute for insurance, or vice versa.'2
  • Coverage starts 30 days after CHW receives the fee, earlier only with proof of prior coverage showing no lapse13.
  • Every claim carries a $100 trade service call fee, 'no matter what the actual cost of the repair or replacement'1.
  • No plan price is printed on any CHW page we read. The price is by quote on its site; the agreement says the Agreement Fee is 'set forth in Your Coverage Details'3.

Side by side, in Choice Home Warranty's words

Left column: what CHW says about its own home warranty. Right column: what CHW says about homeowners insurance. A dash means the CHW pages we read do not state it. We do not describe insurance policies beyond what CHW states.

QuestionHome warranty (CHW's words)Homeowners insurance (CHW's words)
What it is1'a service contract' for 'covered repairs of their major systems and appliances that break down due to normal wear and tear''hazard insurance'; 'required when you sign up for a mortgage'
What it pays for2Systems and appliances listed on the plan: heating, electrical, plumbing, water heater, kitchen appliances and more'items damaged in fires, flooding, wind, and other natural disasters'; the article adds structure, contents, personal items, temporary living expenses and liability claims
What it does not pay for2'known or unknown pre-existing conditions, misuse, abuse, or failure to clean or maintain'; 'items that have been damaged due to disaster or misuse''Insurance will not repair or replace appliances or systems due to normal wear and tear.'
When coverage starts1'30 days after enrollment and receipt of applicable contract fees'Not stated by the source
Term3'typically 365 days'; a Fixed-Term Plan is '1 year or greater', a Monthly Plan has a monthly termNot stated by the source
Cost per claim1'$100 trade service call fee per claim', paid to the technicianDeductible 'can be $500-$1,000 or higher' (CHW's 2014 article; no insurer named)
Dollar limits3'$3,000 per 12-month period for each Covered Item'; $500 for access; $500 or $250 on several add-onsNot stated by the source
Cash instead of repair3CHW 'reserves the right to offer cash back in lieu of repair or replacement' at its actual cost, 'which at times may be less than retail'The article describes a claim adjuster and a sum offered to repair the damage
Plan price1Not stated by the sourceNot stated by the source
Who sells it1Choice Home Warranty (in California, Home Service Club of California, Inc.)Not stated by the source
SourceCHW common questions, user agreement, what's coveredRead Oct 14, 2026CHW common questions and its 2014 articleRead Oct 14, 2026

Plan price: CHW publishes none on the pages read; price by quote on its site. Insurance figures: CHW's article is dated September 22, 2014 and cites a third party for premiums, so no premium figure is shown here.

What the home warranty is, in CHW's words

Choice Home Warranty answers 'What is a home warranty?' with: 'A home warranty is a service contract that helps protect homeowners against the cost of unexpected covered repairs of their major systems and appliances that break down due to normal wear and tear.'1 The agreement repeats the test: systems 'must become inoperative due to normal wear and tear' and 'must be in proper working order on the effective date'3.

Age does not matter, condition does. 'The age of a home or its systems and appliances does not matter. We cover items that are in good working condition and properly maintained.'1 CHW does not require an inspection but says 'it is a good idea to get your home inspected', because 'the contract does not cover any known or unknown pre-existing conditions'1.

Two plans and a list of add-ons. The what's-covered table shows two plan columns. Both mark heating, electrical, plumbing, plumbing stoppage, water heater, whirlpool bathtub, oven/range/stove, cooktop, dishwasher, built-in microwave, garbage disposal, ductwork, garage door opener and ceiling and exhaust fans; only the first column also marks air conditioning, refrigerator, clothes washer and clothes dryer. Optional coverage: central vacuum, limited roof leak, septic system, second refrigerator, stand alone freezer, septic tank pumping4. The agreement's optional section also lists pool and spa equipment, well pump, sump pump, sprinkler system, stand alone ice-maker and trash compactor3.

Cash in lieu. 'If a covered item that needs to be replaced is not available, CHW will offer a cash payment for the amount of CHW's replacement cost, which at times may be less than retail.'1 The agreement adds that cash 'does not include the costs of shipping, tax, or installation' and that after a cash replacement 'You may not make subsequent claims on such Covered Item for 12 months'3.

What CHW says homeowners insurance is

From the FAQ: 'Your homeowner's insurance is hazard insurance, and only covers items damaged in fires, flooding, wind, and other natural disasters. A home warranty repairs properly maintained household appliances and mechanical systems that fail due to normal wear and tear.'1

From CHW's article: 'Home insurance is for emergencies, while a home warranty is for everyday wear. Home insurance is designed to protect your home in case of accidents or emergencies: natural disasters, fire, theft, vandalism, and other major events that can cause damage.' It lists the coverages 'typically offered in most home insurance policies' as the home's structure and contents, personal items, temporary living expenses and liability claims, and says insurance 'will not repair or replace appliances or systems due to normal wear and tear'2.

What this page does not do. It does not describe any insurer's policy. The article is CHW's and is dated September 22, 2014; its general price figures and the premium figure it attributes to a third party are left out. For what your own policy covers, read the policy.

Why people buy both, and what to read first

CHW's own line is 'A home warranty is not a substitute for insurance, or vice versa.'2 Its buyers-and-sellers page describes the contract as '100% transferable' for sellers and promises buyers 'Low service call fees, regardless of the actual service cost'5.

Before paying for a home warranty, read three things in the agreement: the 30-day start3, the $100 fee per claim1, and the limits of liability, which cap CHW at '$3,000 per 12-month period for each Covered Item' with lower caps on several add-ons3. Our fee and limits guide works through the arithmetic, and the timing guide covers when to enroll so cover is active on move-in day.

The company behind these quotes

Good for a service contract on the systems and appliances at the new address

Choice Home Warranty

Coverage starts
30 days after the fee is received
Per claim
$100 trade service call fee (FAQ)
Plan price
By quote on its site
See plans on Choice Home WarrantyOpens Choice Home Warranty's site. Not a referral link.
What to check first
  • The Coverage Details page that states your Agreement Fee and Service Fee
  • The $3,000 per-item limit and the $500 and $250 lower limits
  • Which add-ons your home needs (well, septic, roof, pool)

Warranty or insurance questions

Is a home warranty insurance?

Not according to Choice Home Warranty. Its pages say 'CHW offers service contracts which are not warranties' and the agreement says 'This is not a contract of insurance.' It is a service contract for covered repairs after normal wear and tear.

Does homeowners insurance cover a broken furnace or water heater?

CHW says insurance 'only covers items damaged in fires, flooding, wind, and other natural disasters' and 'will not repair or replace appliances or systems due to normal wear and tear.' Read your own policy for what it covers; this page quotes only CHW.

Does CHW publish a plan price?

No. None of the five CHW pages read on Oct 14, 2026 prints a plan price. The agreement says the Agreement Fee is 'set forth in Your Coverage Details'. The price is by quote on its site.

What does the $100 pay for?

It is the 'trade service call fee per claim', paid 'directly to the technician that comes to your home', 'no matter what the actual cost of the repair or replacement'. CHW says it 'may be lower depending on discounts available'.

Does a home warranty replace a home inspection?

CHW says no inspection is required but 'it is a good idea', because known or unknown pre-existing conditions are not covered.

Sources

  1. Common questions (read Oct 14, 2026)Choice Home Warranty, read Oct 14, 2026
  2. Home Warranties vs Home Insurance: What's the Difference? (article posted September 22, 2014, read Oct 14, 2026)Choice Home Warranty, read Oct 14, 2026
  3. User agreement, sample terms of service (read Oct 14, 2026)Choice Home Warranty, read Oct 14, 2026
  4. What's covered (read Oct 14, 2026)Choice Home Warranty, read Oct 14, 2026
  5. Home warranties for buyers and sellers (read Oct 14, 2026)Choice Home Warranty, read Oct 14, 2026

About this page

We may be paid when you use partner links on this page.

Prices, plan terms and service areas belong to each company and can change. The company's own page is the final word on price, availability and terms.

MoveMate Local is not a mover, broker, carrier or insurer, and does not pass your details to anyone.